My NYC Food Bucket List: Best Restaurants In NYC

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission, at no extra cost to you, if you purchase through a link. This helps me keep the Sick Girl Travels blog running while providing you with high-quality product recommendations and great travel deals. Please see my full disclosure for further information. Thanks for your support!

New York City is a foodie’s paradise. Everywhere you look in the five boroughs, there’s amazing cuisine from across the globe. But this can be overwhelming, especially if it’s your first time in the city. New restaurants are popping up all the time. Thankfully, you have me to be your culinary guide. I’ve eaten my way through NYC on more than one occasion, and I have a ton of amazing recommendations for everything from classic NY pizza and cheesecake to outstanding fried chicken, Persian, and Thai cuisines. Whether you’re in Midtown West or Williamsburg, I’ve got the perfect place for you. This is my NYC food bucket list: aka the best restaurants in NYC.

Accessibility and Dining in NYC

Let’s be real: when you’re in New York City with a chronic illness or disability, the stakes are high. You need food — good food — and you need it now, ideally somewhere you don’t have to climb a staircase, fight for a table, or wait 90 minutes just to be told, “We’re out of the truffle fries.”

I’ve spent a lot of time eating my way through NYC while managing fatigue, joint pain, and the never-ending joy that is invisible illness. So I’m here to help you skip the stress and head straight for the spots that serve up the best food, best vibes, and best accessibility — all without draining your energy meter. If you need a reservation, I have noted it below.

Speaking of reservations, if you’re visiting from out of town and need a place to stay in New York City or other cities worldwide, check out Hotels and Stays.

1. CheLi – East Village

What to order: The Hunan Beef if you like spicy. And I LOVE spicy.
Why it’s great: Topping the list of my must-eat places in NYC is CheLi. The menu is massive and truly has something for everyone. Plus, it’s a great opportunity to share dishes. Ranked #15 on the New York Times’ top 100 restaurants and listed in the Michelin Guide, CheLi definitely deserves all its hype and recognition.

Accessibility: The entrance has a flight of stairs; however, there is a wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible restrooms.
Jenn’s Note: This Shanghai-style Chinese spot offers traditional favorites along with some more adventurous dishes like kidneys and crispy pork knuckles. The only downside is that they don’t have a full bar. But they have a nice selection of beer, wine, soju, and sake.

Address: 19 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003

2. Buvette – West Village

What to order: The Croque Monsieur, a cappuccino, and literally anything else on the menu.
Why it’s great: Cozy French café vibes without the pretentiousness. It’s charming, intimate, and serves comfort food that feels elevated.
Accessibility: No stairs at the entrance, though space inside is tight — best for manual chairs or those comfortable with smaller cafés.
Jenn’s Note: Come early on weekdays for less crowd stress.

Address: 42 Grove St, New York, NY 10014

3. Katz Deli – East Village

What to order: The pastrami!
Why it’s great: One of the most iconic places to eat in NYC, Katz is legendary, and with good reason. Come see where Meg Ryan famously faked her orgasm in When Harry Met Sally and enjoy one of their massive sandwiches.
Accessibility: Katz has a wheelchair-accessible entrance and restroom.
Jenn’s Note: Hold on to your ticket, or you’ll have to pay extra when you leave.

Address: 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002

4. Russ & Daughters Café – Lower East Side

What to order: The classic bagel with lox and cream cheese. Add a chocolate egg cream for retro joy.
Why it’s great: Iconic New York Jewish deli meets modern brunch. It’s part history lesson, part carb heaven.
Accessibility: Fully wheelchair accessible with wide tables and accessible restrooms.
Jenn’s Note: Avoid the weekend brunch rush. They don’t take reservations, so plan for off-peak hours.

Address: 127 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002

5. Au Cheval – SoHo

What to order: The burgers
Why it’s great: Au Cheval reimagines traditional fare, from roasted bone marrow to salads, griddled cheeseburgers to seafood, and of course, steaks. Accessibility: The restaurant has a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible seating, and wheelchair-accessible restrooms. Jenn’s Note: Try the roasted bone marrow; you’ll thank me.

Address: 33 Cortlandt Alley, New York, NY 10013

6. Rubirosa – Nolita

What to order: The vodka pizza. You’re welcome.
Why it’s great: A cozy, trendy-but-still-fun pizza spot with major flavor and gluten-free options that don’t taste like cardboard.
Accessibility: Accessible entrance, but it gets very crowded during peak hours.
Jenn’s Note: Go for lunch midweek if mobility is an issue — dinner lines can be intense.

Address: 235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012

7. Balthazar – SoHo

What to order: The bread basket! It’s a great way to start your meal and comes with a wide variety of breads and baked goods, including monkey bread.
Why it’s great: One of the top places to eat in NYC, Balthazar is a must-visit brunch spot. (My family goes every Thanksgiving.) Try the brioche French toast, eggs Benedict, and apple cinnamon pancakes.
Accessibility: Wheelchair accessible. Restrooms are downstairs, but there is an elevator inside to bypass the steps.
Jenn’s Note: Make reservations as it gets busy.

Address: 80 Spring St, New York, NY 10012

8. Momoya – Chelsea

What to order: The spicy tuna roll, miso cod, and lychee martini.
Why it’s great: Upscale sushi without the Midtown chaos. Feels like a local secret.
Accessibility: Step-free entrance and ADA-compliant bathroom — rare for a Chelsea spot.
Jenn’s Note: A great place to eat before visiting nearby art galleries or Little Island.

Address: 185 7th Ave, New York, NY 10011-1804

9. Cafe Reggio – West Village

What to order: The cappuccino
Why it’s great: Opened by Domenico Parisi, an Italian immigrant, it’s renowned for being the first cafe in the United States to serve cappuccinos.
Accessibility: The cafe entrance is wheelchair accessible and offers wheelchair accessible seating.
Jenn’s Note: It’s the most popular cafe in Greenwich Village, but there’s plenty of seating inside and out, so you shouldn’t have too much trouble getting in.

Address: 119 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012

10. Juniors – Times Square

What to order: The strawberry cheesecake
Why it’s great: Juniors is a well-known New York City restaurant and bakery, famous for its New York-style cheesecake and deli offerings. Accessibility: Juniors has several locations around the city, but they are all wheelchair accessible.
Jenn’s Note: Get yourself a roast beef or pastrami sandwich. These sky-high sandwiches are out-of-this-world amazing.

Address: 1515 Broadway, W 45th St, New York, NY 10036

11. Hwa Yuan Szechuan Inn – Chinatown

What to order: The cold sesame noodles
Why it’s great: One of my must-eat restaurants in NYC, this place invented cold sesame noodles. In fact, The New York Times called them “the best cold sesame noodles Manhattan ever tasted.” The Beijing duck is also some of the best in the neighborhood. Accessibility: The restaurant is wheelchair accessible.
Jenn’s Note: Come for the cold sesame noodles, stay for the kung pao.

Address: 42 E Broadway, New York, NY 10002

12. Tacombi – Flatiron

What to order: Al pastor tacos, corn esquites, and a fresh watermelon agua fresca.
Why it’s great: Cool design, casual vibes, and tacos that actually fill you up.
Accessibility: Spacious layout with accessible restrooms and no stairs.
Jenn’s Note: Also a good stop if you’re near Madison Square Park (hello, wheelchair-friendly green space with killer views).

Address: 23 W 33rd St, New York, NY

13. Junoon – Chelsea

What to order: Oriya Mutton Curry.

Why it’s great: Sophisticated Indian cuisine and a notable wine list offered in an elegant space with ornate accents.

Accessibility: The restaurant is wheelchair-accessible.
Jenn’s Note: If you want to try the swankiest Indian restaurant in NYC, you must head to Junoon.

Address: 19 W 24th St, New York, NY 10010

14. Thai Diner – Nolita

What to order: Thai tea French toast for brunch, khao soi for dinner.
Why it’s great: Comfort food that mashes up classic diner kitsch with bold Thai flavors.

Accessibility: Step-free entrance, tables with good clearance, and staff who are genuinely helpful.
Jenn’s Note: The menu is huge, and portions are shareable. Just know that reservations are nearly impossible to get, so you need to plan weeks in advance.

Address: 186 Mott St, New York, NY 10012

15. Lexington Candy Shop – Upper East Side

What to order: The delicious shakes and malts. Yes, the sandwiches are good, but you come for the ice cream.
Why it’s great: Get a slice of old New York history at this 100-year-old diner.
Accessibility: The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, but it’s a tight squeeze into the bathroom, so wheelchair users beware.
Jenn’s Note: The space is somewhat cramped due to the historic nature of the building. There is usually a line outside, but it moves fairly quickly.

Address: 1226 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028

16. Trinity Place Bar And Restaurant – Financial District

What to order: The Duck Leg Confit Risotto.

Why it’s great: This lower Manhattan bar is set up in an old bank vault that rests beneath a skyscraper that hides even more historic splendor.

Accessibility: The restaurant is wheelchair accessible.
Jenn’s Note: The food is incredible, and the atmosphere can’t be beat.

Address: 115 Broadway, New York, NY 10006

17. Westville – Multiple Locations (Go to Hudson or East Village)

What to order: Market plate (mix and match veggie sides), sweet potato fries, grilled chicken.
Why it’s great: It’s your clean-eating-but-not-boring backup plan when you feel too inflamed for pizza.
Accessibility: Most locations have step-free entrances and flexible seating.
Jenn’s Note: Their veggie plate is like eating healthy, but it still tastes like food.

Address: 333 Hudson St, New York, NY 10013

18. Nobu 57 – Midtown

What to order: The black miso cod and the yellowtail sashimi
Why it’s great: It’s a successful, worldwide chain for a reason. From the lychee martinis to the yellowtail sashimi, Nobu is perfection.
Accessibility: There is an elevator and wheelchair accessible restrooms.
Jenn’s Note: This is one of the pricier suggestions on my list. But if you’re looking to splurge on high-quality Japanese cuisine, look no further than Nobu.

Address: 40 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019

19. Peppino’s Pizza – Brooklyn

What to order: The pizza, of course. But the meatballs are no slouch either.
Why it’s great: Classic New York pizza in the heart of Brooklyn. New Yorkers love Peppino’s, and you will too.
Accessibility: The restaurant and restrooms are wheelchair accessible.
Jenn’s Note: The brick oven pizza and hearty portions of Italian classics are served up in this family-run establishment that has several locations throughout the city.

Address: 469 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

20. Devoción Coffee – Williamsburg or Flatiron

What to order: Cold brew, guava pastry, and a moment of peace in the indoor garden.
Why it’s great: It’s one of the most beautiful cafés in NYC — and a surprisingly quiet spot to recharge.
Accessibility: Both locations are accessible; Williamsburg has more space.
Jenn’s Note: Come here when you need a break from stimulation but still want to feel “in the city.”

21. Persepolis – Upper East Side

What to order: The lamb skewers
Why it’s great: From the Michelin guide, “Silky-smooth spreads, homemade yogurt, grilled meats and fragrantly spiced stews have solidified Persepolis’ reputation as one of the city’s finest Persian restaurants.” I’ll go one step further and say it’s one of the best Middle Eastern restaurants in the city. Accessibility: The restaurant is roomy and wheelchair-accessible.
Jenn’s Note: Did you know Persian food is the oldest cuisine in the world? See what all the fuss is about and try some hearty stews and banging kabobs.

Address: 1407 2nd Avenue, between 73rd st &, E 74th St, New York, NY 10021

22. Russian Tea Room – Midtown

What to order: Potato Vareniki, the Ukrainian version of pierogi.

Why it’s great: It’s famous as a gathering place for those in the entertainment industry.
Accessibility: It has wheelchair accessible entrances and seating.

Jenn’s Note: Get sauced on vodka martinis as you take in the ambiance of the historic Russian Tea Room. If you’re looking to splurge, do try the caviar. It’s the perfect spot to grab a bite if you find yourself in the theater district.

Address: 150 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019

23. Magnolia Bakery – Multiple Locations

What to order: Banana pudding. No questions.
Why it’s great: It’s iconic, it’s sweet, and it travels well if you’re flaring in a hotel room.
Accessibility: All major locations have step-free access and some outdoor seating.
Jenn’s Note: Order ahead online to skip lines.

Address: Multiple locations throughout the city.

24. Soothr Thai – East Village

What to order: Their regional specialties, like Hat Yai Chicken
Why it’s great: It’s an intimate space with al fresco dining, offering Thai noodles and soups, plus outrageously delicious cocktails. Accessibility: The tight space makes navigating with a wheelchair difficult. However, it does have a wheelchair accessible entrance and seating.
Jenn’s Note: The menu is sizable, so bring a few friends so you can try a variety of dishes. Everything we had was amazingly good.

Address: 204 E 13th St, New York, NY 10003

25. Eleven Madison Park – Flatiron District

What to order: Dosa with black truffle and parmesan, and a halibut roasted with black shallot and shiitake mushroom.

Why it’s great: Upscale American tasting menus from chef Daniel Humm served in a high-ceilinged Art Deco space. And they’re the winner of the James Beard Foundation’s Outstanding Chef, Outstanding Service, Outstanding Pastry Chef, Outstanding Restaurant, Best Chef: NYC, Outstanding Wine Service, and Rising Star Chef awards.

Accessibility: The restaurant has a wheelchair-accessible entrance, seating, and restrooms. They also offer digital accessibility for their website, aiming to conform to WCAG guidelines.
Jenn’s Note: This is a Michelin 3-star restaurant, and it’s ranked as one of the world’s 50 best restaurants, making it by far the fanciest spot on my list.

Address: 11 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10010

Final Thoughts from a Chronically Ill Food-Lover Who Just Wants to Sit Down

NYC might be big and busy, but it’s also full of places that welcome everyone, even if you walk a little slower, need a ramp, or need to rest between meals. From the Upper West Side to Brooklyn, these restaurants aren’t just “pretty accessible for New York.” They’re actually good, and they’ve got a seat waiting for you.

Got a favorite spot I should try next time I’m in the city? Let me know — my stomach and I are always accepting recommendations.

Frequently Asked Questions About Eating in New York City

What foods should be on a New York City food bucket list?

Essential New York foods include a classic pizza slice, bagel with lox and cream cheese, pastrami on rye, New York cheesecake, a diner breakfast, dumplings, street-cart food, and something sweet from a neighborhood bakery. My list covers the classics at places like Katz’s Delicatessen, Russ & Daughters Café, Junior’s, Rubirosa, Peppino’s, and Magnolia Bakery, along with outstanding Thai, Persian, Indian, Chinese, Japanese, French, and Mexican restaurants.

What are the most iconic restaurants in New York City?

Katz’s Delicatessen, Balthazar, Junior’s, Café Reggio, the Russian Tea Room, Russ & Daughters Café, and Eleven Madison Park are among the most recognizable restaurants on this list. Some are famous for their history, others for their food, and a few for making your credit card quietly whimper.

Which NYC neighborhoods are best for food?

The East Village and Lower East Side are excellent for delis, Chinese food, Thai food, and casual dining. SoHo, Nolita, and the West Village offer trendy restaurants, bakeries, cafés, and brunch spots. Chelsea and Flatiron have everything from sushi to fine dining, while Brooklyn is essential for pizza, coffee, and neighborhood restaurants.

How can I organize an NYC food crawl by neighborhood?

Group restaurants together so you spend more time eating and less time crossing Manhattan:

• Lower East Side and East Village: Katz’s Delicatessen, Russ & Daughters Café, CheLi, and Soothr Thai
• SoHo and Nolita: Balthazar, Au Cheval, Rubirosa, and Thai Diner
• West Village: Buvette and Café Reggio
• Chelsea and Flatiron: Momoya, Junoon, and Eleven Madison Park
• Midtown: Junior’s, Nobu 57, and the Russian Tea Room
• Upper East Side: Lexington Candy Shop and Persepolis

Your stomach may believe it can complete the entire route in one day. Your stomach is lying.

Do you need reservations at NYC restaurants?

Reservations are strongly recommended for Balthazar, Rubirosa, Nobu 57, Junoon, Eleven Madison Park, and other popular sit-down restaurants. Some restaurants release tables only a few weeks in advance, while others reserve space for walk-ins. Check each restaurant’s current policy directly because reservation systems and release dates frequently change.

What is the best time to eat at popular NYC restaurants?

Weekday lunches and early dinners are usually less crowded than weekend brunches or prime dinner hours. Try arriving around 11:30 a.m. for lunch or between 5:00 and 5:30 p.m. for dinner. Off-peak dining is especially helpful if you need more room for a wheelchair, cannot stand in a long line, or simply object to waiting 90 minutes for eggs.

Are New York City restaurants wheelchair accessible?

Some are, but accessibility varies dramatically. Newer and larger restaurants are more likely to have step-free entrances and accessible restrooms, while small cafés and restaurants in historic buildings may have steps, narrow aisles, or basement bathrooms.

New York City has a voluntary Wheelchair Friendly decal program, and the city maintains a map of restaurants that self-report meeting its accessibility criteria. However, you should still contact the restaurant to confirm the entrance, seating, and restroom will work for your specific mobility device. See the city’s accessible restaurant information for additional planning help.

Which restaurants on this list are better for wheelchair users?

Russ & Daughters Café, Momoya, Tacombi, Junoon, Nobu 57, Eleven Madison Park, and several other restaurants on this list report step-free entrances, accessible seating, or accessible restrooms. Accessibility can change, however, so verify details when reserving.

Smaller restaurants such as Buvette, Lexington Candy Shop, and Soothr may be step-free but have tight interiors. A step-free entrance does not automatically mean there is room to turn, transfer, or use the restroom comfortably.

What accessibility questions should I ask a restaurant?

Ask whether there is a step-free entrance, how wide the doorway is, whether an elevator is required, and whether the accessible entrance is the same as the main entrance. You should also confirm table clearance, restroom accessibility, aisle width, and whether staff can remove a chair for your wheelchair.

If you use a power wheelchair or scooter, give the restaurant its approximate dimensions. “Wheelchair accessible” can mean anything from genuinely accessible to “there’s only one step and three employees can lift you,” which is not the same thing.

How can disabled diners travel between NYC restaurants?

Accessible subway stations can be useful, but elevators occasionally go out of service. Check the MTA’s accessible-station list and real-time elevator status before traveling.

City buses are often easier for wheelchair users because they have ramps or lifts, although traffic can make trips slow. Accessible taxis and rideshare vehicles are another option when fatigue, weather, or distance makes public transportation impractical.

What are the best NYC restaurants for a low-energy day?

Choose one neighborhood and make a reservation somewhere with comfortable seating and an accessible restroom. Momoya can be paired with nearby Chelsea attractions, while Tacombi works well with Madison Square Park. Devoción is a good option when you need coffee, seating, and a break from the city’s relentless commitment to noise.

Takeout is also a completely legitimate New York dining experience. Magnolia Bakery’s banana pudding tastes just as good in a hotel bed while wearing pajamas.

Is it expensive to eat in New York City?

It can be, but it does not have to be. Pizza slices, bagels, tacos, dumplings, bakery treats, and casual lunch specials can help balance more expensive meals. Fine-dining restaurants such as Eleven Madison Park and Nobu 57 require a much larger budget.

Remember that restaurant prices generally do not include New York City’s 8.875% sales tax or gratuity. The city confirms the current tax rate on its official sales-tax page.

How much should you tip at NYC restaurants?

A tip of approximately 20% is customary for table service. Some restaurants automatically add gratuity for larger groups, tasting menus, or special events, so check the bill before adding another tip. For counter service, cafés, and takeout, tipping is appreciated but generally more flexible.

Can vegetarians and vegans eat well in NYC?

Very well. Westville has customizable vegetable plates, Thai Diner and Soothr offer several plant-forward dishes, and many restaurants can modify menu items. Fine-dining restaurants may also provide vegetarian or vegan tasting options with advance notice.

Always verify that a dish is fully vegetarian or vegan, since broths, sauces, and garnishes may contain meat, fish sauce, dairy, or eggs.

Are there gluten-free restaurants in New York City?

NYC has numerous gluten-free choices, and Rubirosa is particularly popular for its gluten-free pizza. Many restaurants can accommodate gluten-free diners, but those with celiac disease should ask about shared fryers, preparation surfaces, soy sauce, and cross-contact before ordering.

How should travelers with food allergies dine in NYC?

Mention serious allergies when making the reservation and again when you arrive. Ask to speak with a manager if necessary, and carry your emergency medication. Menus and recipes can change, so do not rely entirely on an old online menu or review.

Are NYC restaurants good for solo diners?

Yes. Counter-service restaurants, cafés, delis, sushi bars, and restaurants with bar seating are particularly comfortable for solo diners. Eating alone may also make it easier to secure a last-minute table at a popular restaurant. You are not lonely—you are simply refusing to share the fries.

Are restaurant health grades important in New York City?

New York City restaurants must display their current health-inspection grade near the entrance. An “A” represents the best inspection score. You can also search current results through the city’s restaurant inspection database.

Can you complete an NYC food bucket list in one trip?

Probably not, and that is part of the fun. New York’s restaurant scene constantly changes, and every neighborhood has places deserving their own list. Pick a few iconic foods, reserve one special meal, explore restaurants near your planned attractions, and leave something for the next visit. Preferably several slices of pizza.